It wasn't because it held 17 rounds in the magazine.
Franklin Armory Delivers G-S173 Binary Kit for Glock 17
Glock 17: Respect the OG Wonder-Nine
Why Did Glock Dub Its First Handgun the Glock 17?, glock 17
GLOCK 19 Gen5 9mm Semi-Auto Pistol
Sig Sauer P220 Legion R2 45 Auto (ACP) Cerakote Pistol, 47% OFF
What Was The First GLOCK Made? The First Five Pistols
Glock Gen 2 Model 17 9mm : What Made Glock so Popular!
Shoot a Glock in Las Vegas, glock 17
A History of Glock Generations - Gun Tests
Shoot a Glock in Las Vegas, glock 17
Used LEO Glock 17: Is Older Better?
You Can Now Buy the Glock Pistol That the U.S. Army Didn't Want
How to Identify Your Glock's Generation – TALON Gun Grips